Apple Feeds the Haters
July 1st, 2010All right, you know that most anyone who doesn’t much care for Apple must be cheering now. The company may be facing some serious trouble with the spectacularly successful iPhone 4 rollout, because of alleged antenna issues.
As you’ve no doubt heard, if you hold the iPhone 4 in your left hand and move your palm and fingers in a certain way, sensitivity goes down the tubes. This symptom is produced by covering those brand new, super sensitive antennas.
This claim appears to be true. Even if you don’t have an iPhone 4 at hand to test, there are loads of YouTube videos showing just how it’s done. But once you master the one-handed salute, is there any way to cope with that state of affairs, other than returning your iPhone for a refund of course?
Well, Apple has given several answers to complaints about the problem. The first, echoed by Steve Jobs, is to just hold it differently, which begs the question of why should you be forced to hold this iPhone any different from any other smartphone, or regular mobile handset for that matter?
The subsequent explanations were rather more descriptive, claiming that this is a problem that can affect any mobile phone, so live with it or use bumpers or a case to shield the antenna region from your sweaty palms.
All well and good, except for the nasty fact that this is the very first time large numbers of people have found reason to complain about a huge drop in performance with an iPhone. More to the point, if you live or travel to an area where signal strength is pretty high, you might not be seriously impacted. Otherwise, you may lose your connection, be it Internet or that important business phone call.
In recent days, the dialog between Steve Jobs and Apple customers on this and other subjects has grown more verbose, although a recent email exchange is reported by Apple to be bogus. But Jobs has hinted at a forthcoming fix in other communications, and Apple has now admitted the problem is actually due to incorrectly displaying signal strength; in other words, you’re seeing the wrong number of bars. According to Apple: “We will issue a free software update within a few weeks that incorporates the corrected formula. Since this mistake has been present since the original iPhone, this software update will also be available for the iPhone 3GS and iPhone 3G.”
At the same time, the legal ambulance chasers in our midst are busy with their class action lawsuits, designed to force Apple to pay for its failures and possible stonewalling about the existence of such a serious product defect. Unfortunately, legal actions of this sort may take years to resolve, and if the complainants actually emerge victorious, the lawyers get paid first, and the customers who were actually hurt end up with little more than a discount coupon so you can buy something else from the company that allegedly injured you.
The real issue is how Apple might have allowed this alleged defect to slip into production, in fact admitting that the signal display has always been incorrect ever since the first iPhone. And why would that bug suddenly become so significant, after tens of millions of iPhones have been sold around the world?
Of course, the truth is that pretty much all mobile phones will exhibit some sort of signal strength degradation if held the “wrong way,” which can vary from device to device.
Such design compromises are evidently the result of FCC regulations, which mandate that handset makers move the antennas as far away from your head as possible, so you don’t fry your brain or develop tumors from excess radiation. That posture forces certain design constraints that certainly make sense, although you’d rather believe you could hold your phone any way you want without hurting performance.
Now if Apple’s promised fix succeeds in its intent, which is displaying the real signal strength on your phone, so it doesn’t change so drastically when you hold it the wrong way, it will only be yet another product glitch in a long line of product glitches.
Apple didn’t help themselves, though, when their initial efforts at corporate spin control were not just uninformed, but sometimes downright insulting. Hold your iPhone differently indeed! At least Steve Jobs seems to understand that this was a serious PR misfire, but his assurances that Apple has the problem under review didn’t come soon enough.
I do hope that the fix is simply software. For Apple to be forced to recall millions of iPhones because of serious design defects might cause a huge black mark on their reputation for unparalleled success, not to mention money lost. It would also give Apple haters and rival companies lots of ammunition to grab a piece of the pie for themselves, and I’m sure Apple didn’t expect it to turn out that way.
Print This Post
it is not a design defect. it is a design trade-off
from an antenna designer:
You see, when the FCC tests are run, the head is required to be in the vicinity of the phone. But, the hand is not!! And the FCC’s tests are not the only tests that must be passed by a candidate product. AT&T has their own requirements for devices put on their network, and antenna efficiency is one of them. I know because I have designed quad-band GSM antennas for the AT&T network. The AT&T test similarly does not require the hand to be on the phone.
So, naturally, the design evolved to meet requirements – and efficient transmission and reception while being held by a human hand are simply not design requirements!
@mysterian1729, Well we can always have a robot do our calling for us. No, wait, that would interfere with the signal. 🙂
Peace,
Gene
@Gene
I find your reply downright insulting, have a care you may find fewer readers as time goes by but then maybe you don’t care.
Have a whatever day…
@AdamC, We call it humor. Unless you’re a robot, why would you be offended?
Peace,
Gene
Apple’s going to really feel the haters when it wins its lawsuit against HTC ( for some 20 patent infringements ) and makes HTC recall all the Android phones violating its patents.
You haven’s seen hate yet til that day comes.
All those idiots that have been plugging the Android phones as equals to iPhones for the sake of not making it look it’s a one horse race and “trying to give people choices,” are really going to express their hate. Or maybe, jsut, maybe, they can come and say that the truth that Android phones are hacks compared to an iPhone.
Consumers that are suing Apple over the iPhone 4 antenna issues are basically attention-grabbing jackasses. It’s not like anyone has gotten injured or killed or had their lives destroyed. All they had to do was return their iPhones and now it’s even simpler since the restocking fee has been waived. Supporting scum-sucking shyster lawyers and wasting taxpayer’s money for court fee’s is unpardonable. All for what? To wait a year or two and get back a few dollars. Sure the law firms will make out like bandits but the idiot plaintiffs will get next to nothing.
By the time the plaintiffs see one penny, chances are the iPhone 6 will be selling in the 15 million unit range every quarter. As it is, the iPhone 4 antenna reception problem will be forgotten in a month. Are those plaintiffs still going to have their iPhone 4s just collecting dust? They’ll refuse to use them because they’re too cheap to buy a case or what? I really don’t see their point. If the plaintiffs lose their class-action suit against Apple they should be made to pay the court fees out of their own pockets for wasting precious court time that could have been used for more potentially dangerous matters.
Hey! Lawsuit jerks. Please return your iPhone 4 because there’s a lot of consumers waiting for them. If you’re too cheap to buy a case, then let someone who’ll appreciate the iPhone 4 have it. Go buy some other smartphone and then good riddance. Jeez, what a bunch of retards.